Why This QB Ranking for 2025 Has Fans Split And What It Says About the NFL Right Now

When I first saw the list of Top Quarterbacks Heading into 2025 I had to look twice. Josh Allen at number one? Jayden Daniels in the top ten before he’s even thrown a pass in the NFL? And somehow, guys like Brock Purdy and Matthew Stafford didn’t even make the cut?

This isn’t just about opinions anymore. It says something deeper about where the league is headed, how we judge greatness, and why fanbases are more divided than ever.

Is Josh Allen Really the Best QB Heading into 2025?

Josh Allen is electric. He’s got the arm, the legs, and the kind of highlight plays that light up Sunday nights. But putting him at the top spot going into 2025 raises eyebrows. Allen has put up elite numbers every year, but those stats haven’t always translated into postseason success. In fact, he’s lost to Patrick Mahomes three times in the playoffs, including the famous 13 second heartbreak in 2022.

So why is he number one now? Some argue he carries more of the offense than Mahomes does. Others say his upside is unmatched when he’s on. But even diehard Bills fans have to admit it’s not easy defending that spot.

If you’re part of Bills Mafia and you’re standing by your QB, check out our Buffalo Bills gear. You’ll want something bold to wear when Allen proves the doubters wrong.

According to Pro Football Focus, Allen ranked number three overall in 2024, behind Mahomes and Lamar.

Lamar at #3, Mahomes at #2, What’s the Real Standard Here?

Putting Lamar Jackson above Patrick Mahomes is gutsy. Lamar had a monster 2023, earned MVP honors again, and looked like the most explosive weapon in the league. But is that enough to vault him above Mahomes, the reigning Super Bowl MVP?

Mahomes is the gold standard for today’s quarterbacks. He’s been to four Super Bowls in five years and came out with three rings. That kind of dominance doesn’t fade overnight. But some argue his 2024 regular season wasn’t as sharp, and the Chiefs looked more human than usual.

So what’s the standard now? Is it about stats? MVP trophies? Playoff magic? Or media buzz?

Fans are split. Lamar is the people’s champ in many circles, but Mahomes still owns January. And when it comes to crunch time, most people still trust number fifteen in red and white.

ESPN’s 2025 MVP Watch shows Mahomes is still the betting favorite even if the hype shifted.

And if you’re backing Lamar this season, our Ravens fan collection has exactly what you need for tailgate season.

Jayden Daniels at #9, Bold or Just Premature?

Now this one really threw me. Jayden Daniels, the rookie from LSU, cracking the top ten before he’s taken a single NFL snap? That’s either genius or madness and there’s no in between.

Washington fans have every right to be excited. Daniels was electric in college, winning the Heisman and rewriting SEC stat sheets. He’s mobile, accurate, and mentally sharp. But to rank him above guys like Stroud, Purdy, and even Stafford? That’s asking a lot from someone who hasn’t faced an NFL defense yet.

What happens if he struggles early? These rankings could age fast. And if he shines? Maybe Fox Sports saw it before anyone else.

For fans who are riding the hype wave, grab something new from our Washington themed shop to show your belief before kickoff.

Learn more about Daniels’ rise in this 2024 Heisman feature.

Brock Purdy and Matthew Stafford Got Snubbed and Fans Know It

Let’s be real. Brock Purdy deserves more respect. He led the 49ers to a Super Bowl appearance, made clutch throws when it mattered, and finished the season with a QBR that ranked top five in the league. Yet somehow, he didn’t crack the top ten?

Same goes for Matthew Stafford. The guy is a Super Bowl champion, still throws darts at age thirty six, and has one of the best deep balls in the league. Leaving both out feels more like narrative fatigue than honest analysis.

NFL.com rated Purdy in their Top Ten QB Efficiency rankings, ahead of multiple names on Fox’s list.

If you’re part of the Faithful or riding with the Rams, we’ve got exclusive team apparel that lets you rep your real QB one with no media hype needed.

Justin Herbert’s Spot Feels Off and It’s Not Just About Wins

Justin Herbert is another name that feels misjudged. Ranked eighth, he’s behind Baker Mayfield and Jared Goff. No disrespect to those two, but Herbert’s physical tools and consistency should put him higher. Yes, the Chargers have underperformed. But that’s not all on him.

Herbert throws one of the best deep balls in football and has shown elite poise under pressure. His injuries last season slowed momentum, but he still finished with over four thousand yards and a solid touchdown to interception ratio.

He might not have the playoff wins yet, but anyone who’s watched him play knows the ceiling is sky high.

Dak and Baker, Do They Belong or Just Familiar Names?

Dak Prescott and Baker Mayfield have had very different paths, but both somehow cracked the top ten. Dak is always steady, good stats, smart decisions, but his playoff letdowns haunt Cowboys fans. Baker had a bounce back season in Tampa Bay, but many still see him as hot and cold.

So do they belong? Maybe. But when you leave off names like Stroud or Stafford to include these two, you’re bound to spark debate.

NFL Top 100 Fans Vote showed Baker outside the top twelve in fan rankings heading into 2025.

Cowboys and Bucs fans, if you’re staying loyal no matter what, you already know what to wear. Our gameday shirts and fan styles have you covered.

Mahomes Fatigue Is Real but Should It Matter?

It sounds strange, but some fans are simply tired of seeing Mahomes at the top. Success fatigue is a real thing. We get used to greatness and start craving new names. That might explain why he was bumped down this year.

But being used to winning isn’t a flaw. It’s a sign of elite consistency. Mahomes has been the face of the league for half a decade for a reason. And when the pressure is highest, he’s usually the one holding the trophy.

So What Does It All Mean for the NFL in 2025?

This year’s QB list isn’t just about rankings. It’s about a league in transition. We’re watching new stars rise, legends age, and storylines collide. Some fans love the drama. Some just want fair recognition. But in the end, we all want the same thing, good football and a reason to believe in our guy.

Where Do You Stand?

Are you rolling with Allen as QB one? Still riding with Mahomes? Hyped about Daniels?
No matter where you land, one thing is for sure. This season is about to be wild.
And if you’re repping your team this fall, make sure your gear is ready.
Explore NFL Themed Hawaiian Shirts and fan shirts now. Bold, breathable, and built for Sundays.